diff --git a/classes/Profile.php b/classes/Profile.php
index 3ac2effe3c..3dbd883dd8 100644
--- a/classes/Profile.php
+++ b/classes/Profile.php
@@ -1325,7 +1325,7 @@ class Profile extends Managed_DataObject
             case Right::EMAILONREPLY:
             case Right::EMAILONSUBSCRIBE:
             case Right::EMAILONFAVE:
-                $result = !$this->isSandboxed();
+                $result = !$this->isSandboxed() && !$this->isSilenced();
                 break;
             case Right::WEBLOGIN:
                 $result = !$this->isSilenced();